Reducing Driving Risk Across Your Workforce
Hear why most crashes are preventable and how leaders can use the 5Keys and telematics data to coach safer driving habits across their crews.
-
Speakers
Nate Douglas | Director of Enterprise Sales | Smith System Driver Risk Management
Melanie Russell | Vimocity
-
View The Transcript
Hi everyone and welcome to this month's live event. Thanks so much for being here. Today, we're talking about something almost everyone on a utility crew does every single day, and that's driving. Crews can spend hours behind the wheel during a shift, and what's interesting is that a lot of the most common driving incidents don't happen out on the highway. They happen during the routine parts of the job that nobody really thinks twice about, like parking, backing up, or maneuvering in a tight space.
Then once crews are out on the road, there's a whole other layer of risk they can't control, and that's the other drivers around them.
So today we're going to talk about the habits that help drivers stay ahead of those risks and what you can do as leaders to reinforce them across your teams.
Just a couple of quick housekeeping items before we jump in. Today's session is being recorded, so we will send that out as a replay via email after. And then please feel free to drop any questions you have in the chat anytime. If we don't get to your question live, we will follow-up with you via email.
Stick around until the end because we do have some free resources to share with you.
My name is Melanie, and I work with Vimosity, and I'll be your moderator today. For those of you who aren't familiar with Vimosity, we work with utility and construction companies to help crews put safety expectations into practice every day.
A big part of that is helping safety and ops leaders reinforce timely risks like heat, fatigue, or soft tissue injuries. And they can use those in pre job briefs, safety meetings, and other conversations they're having with crews.
We also work with companies to show what safe, effective work looks like for a specific task. The whole goal is just to make safe, effective work easier to reinforce every day, not just once during an annual training.
I'm really excited about our guest today. Nate is the Director of Enterprise Sales at Smith System. He spent more than a decade working with fleet safety and transportation professionals on reducing driver risk.
Nate, thank you so much for joining us. Before we hop into our conversation, can you tell everyone a little bit about your background and the work you're doing with Smith System today?
Yeah. Thanks, Melanie. Thanks for having me, and thanks to the Vimosity team for putting this webinar on.
Nate Douglas, I've been with Smith System, as you mentioned, over a decade. I work with a majority of the Fortune 100 and Fortune 500 companies to help equip their employees with the tools to stay safe when behind the wheel. A lot of that, a lot of the companies that we work with are in the utility sector and construction sector. It's probably one of our largest vertical markets, but also work with a wide variety of other fleet types from pharmaceutical companies to the heavy haul tractor trailer type companies and anything and everything in between. Basically, if an employee's driving on company business or on behalf of their employer in their own vehicle, then they're a potential client, for Smith System because they're putting their employer at risk.
Crashes are the number one cause of on the job injuries and fatalities in The United States. It's just everyday driving. And so we're here to help keep, employees safe and give them the tools they need to arrive home safely every day.
Yeah. Thank you for the introduction. And I think a great place to start is to talk about the foundation Smith's system is built on, and that's the five keys.
So what are those and why do they matter?
Yeah. So the five keys are, as you mentioned, the foundation of everything that we are and everything that we do. So typically when someone that has some familiarity with the Smith system...
Oh, Nate. Sorry to interrupt you there. It looks like you went on mute for a sec.
All right. Sorry about that. I'm sorry. I didn't know how that happened. I wasn't touching anything.
Anyway, the five keys are the foundation of everything that we are and everything that we do. So typically, someone thinks Smith system, they think the five keys and this is what they are. So back in 1952, Harold Smith, so the Smith in Smith system, found that a lot of employees were getting into crashes when driving in everyday traffic. And in some scenarios, we were killing more people on the roads than were dying in World War II.
And so coming back from the war, he saw this as a really important issue that he wanted to do something about.
Having a driver's license at the time did obviously ensure that a driver was going to be a safe one. So how do we equip drivers with the tools to maneuver through traffic more safely was kind of his goal.
And so, basically, he reduced the problem down to, lack of three ingredients, essentially. Lack of space. Obviously, if two objects occupy the same space at the same time, you're gonna have a crash. So whether it's a vehicle in another vehicle, a vehicle in a light pole or a mailbox, or a vehicle in a pedestrian, you need to surround the vehicle with space.
And then another common ingredient he found when a crash occurred was in talking to that driver and understanding what happened, typically, the driver's response was I didn't see x. Right? I didn't see the parked car. I didn't see the yellow boulard in the yard.
I didn't see the car parked car in the...
In my blind spot. So how do you equip drivers with better awareness and visibility so that they're not having to say that as often? So essentially better space for the vehicle, better visibility for the driver. And if the drivers have those two elements, then they have more time Time to be able to identify potential problem, come up with a solution for that problem, and then have enough time to act on it.
So space, visibility, and time. How do we get the drivers that? And that's where he came up with the five keys to space cushion driving to...
In order to equip drivers with the tools to achieve space, visibility, and time.
They are copyrighted and trademarked. It's one of the smartest decisions he made, so that they were his, and they are aim high in steering, get the big picture, keep your eyes moving, leave yourself enough, and make sure they see you. And these... This is what he came up with in 1952, so they haven't changed since. There's not a second one of drivers not behind the wheel, and they could be using any of these five keys when driving.
And their longevity is kind of a testament to their effectiveness. It's... They're the OG of the driver safety world. So it's, you know, it's it's it's works, and it's been around for a long time for a reason.
Yeah. And that's so helpful. And I I think that having that framework in our heads as we continue the conversation is key, no pun intended.
Yes.
So with those in mind, when you look specifically at utility fleets, what types of driving incidents or risks tend to show up the most?
Yeah. So there's... Risk can be spread... Looked at in two different ways. So most of the utility providers that I work with in that space, most of them have a really big problem with backing, parking, and close quarter maneuvers, hitting fixed objects. So it's a high frequency, low severity type maneuver.
Low severity because it's slow speeds. If you do hit something, typically, it's not a high enough speed to bring about significant damage, but it's really frustrating for the safety professionals and the kind of learning and training development professionals that I talked to because they're all preventable in nature. So the yellow boulard in the yard that a driver may have hit didn't grow legs and kind of walk around and place itself behind the vehicle and come out of nowhere. No.
It's always been there. The driver that was behind the wheel didn't basically go through the right mental exercises, the right preparation, understanding what's going on around the vehicle, basically not applying the five keys when approaching and getting in the vehicle and maneuvering. So frustrating for safety professionals because they're so easy to prevent in nature. Thankfully, that they...
They're not as severe as something like a rollover, which does happen. Thankfully, some of the companies I have talked to, it's not quite as frequent, but it's obviously catastrophic with regards to the risk that it poses to the employee, but obviously the damage to the equipment as well. So there are basically two different ways to basically assess the risk, both the high high severity, low frequency ones, but then there's also a high frequency, low severity element to it that requires some different approaches to help give drivers the tools to avoid those situations.
Yeah. And I would assume that some of that is around being comfortable or feeling comfortable before the incidents happen that happen most likely, like you're talking about backing into something.
So can you dive a little bit deeper into how does getting comfortable behind the wheel start to affect the way that someone does drive?
Yeah. So there's two different ways you can look at it. There's obviously comfortable, with the vehicle in itself. There are some scenarios, I'll speak to a utility company, where someone is handed the keys to a vehicle that's different than what they drive normally in every day... Everyday driving environments. And so they don't understand how big the blind area is on that vehicle, where the pivot point is that they have to make a really tight turn or go down an alley or how big the overhang is on it. So, there's those types of elements where vehicle familiarity is really important and a lot of training and policies that can be put in place to help give drivers, basically, the safeguards to avoid, putting themselves in a situation where they're maneuvering a vehicle that they may not be very familiar with.
The Smith system training itself will also help with regards to helping a driver become feel comfortable not only with the vehicle that they're driving themselves, but just maneuvering through traffic, especially sometimes in dense urban areas or in high traffic areas where driving can be really stressful. Right? So if you're in a dense urban environment, it's rush hour. Drivers need to understand that you're not going to try to...
You're not going to be able to save time rushing through traffic. You're not going to be able to save time riding someone's bumper to prevent other people from jumping in in front of you. It's not gonna bump you back to the terminal wherever you started the day or the job site where you are trying to end the day. So when you start implementing the Smith system and the five keys in your everyday driving, you become much more relaxed and you become much more aware.
And when you're much more aware of what your...
Is going on around you, you're much less prone to surprise. Okay. So so we've all been in those driving scenarios where you've had something come out of nowhere that was unexpected, and it's really hard to suppress the feeling of could be anger or frustration.
And so the more you can equip your employees with the tools to become aware, you're not going to be surprised. You're going to be a lot more relaxed, and you'll be able to get to your job site or home in a much more healthy mental state than you would without using the five keys in your everyday driving.
Yeah. And that's so helpful. And we've talked a little bit about what's in the driver's control, right? But the other hard part about driving is everyone else on the road. So can you talk a little bit about how should drivers prepare for someone else making the wrong decision when they're out on the road?
Definitely. So National Safety Council actually does a has done a poll where basically they ask all of the respondents in this survey, and it's about 30,000 of them. Do you consider yourself an excellent above average, average, below average, or poor driver? So five different kind of answers that they can provide.
And over 90% consider themselves excellent or above average in the response to this survey. So we all know it when we go out on the road on a commute or to run to the grocery store or pick up the kids from practice, whatever it may be, do we think really 90...
Over 90% of the drivers are excellent or above average? The answer's probably no because how many of us have a family member or a coworker that scare us whenever we get in the vehicle with them? So it's an eye opening survey result because it highlights there is a problem. And, obviously, as a society, we see it, both with how drivers are performing, but just the frequency with which we see crashes.
We know that crashes are killing about forty three to forty four thousand people every year, and crashes are really expensive. The total cost to society in The United States is over $1,000,000,000,000 a year. It's it's a problem. And so having the five keys really helps insulate us in that environment, which is very dangerous and costly.
So, again, it's all about space cushion driving at the end of the day. So utilizing the five keys by positioning ourselves in traffic where a driver that is near us, if they were to...
If you were to assume kind of the worst possible maneuver that that driver could make that could endanger you, you've got plenty of space to avoid it at the end of the day. So whether it's driving through everyday traffic, how you approach an intersection, or how you even enter an intersection or leave an intersection, there's a lot of techniques with the five keys that can really help, again, drive your awareness but help surround your vehicle with space to be able to account for the occasional mistakes that we might make because we're not perfect, but certainly account for the mistakes of all of the drivers that are around us.
Yeah. You bring up a lot of great points and just bringing up how that extra space can really make a huge difference out in the road.
And something you brought up actually in that answer that I think we should definitely dive into and was a learning for me was, we hear the words accident and crash used pretty interchangeably. And does the language we use around driving incidents matter?
It definitely does. Certainly for safety professionals, would say, who are wanting to instill a culture in their companies and organizations of accountability.
Accident, if you were to look it up in Merriam Webster's dictionary, implies basically a...
It's an act of God, something outside of one's control, something that you there was nothing that could have been done. It was just really bad luck. So, what we...
At Smith System, as we're basically consulting with, partnering with, and helping our clients implement our programs is helping them understand that a lot of what they, might consider non preventable really is preventable. And so we prefer the term crash just because, I mean, that's what it is, But, also, it helps instill, basically, that mindset internally of, no. There's a lot you can do to avoid these, incidents, these crashes. There's, it's with proper training.
Again, implementing the five keys, surrounding yourself with space. These are all techniques that we're equipping drivers to maneuver through traffic more safely, avoid crashes because most of them are preventable in nature. Drivers just need to be given the right training and the right tools to avoid them. And so when you think of it as a training focused, kind of initiative rather than something that you toss the keys to someone, kinda hope they get there at the end of the day.
And if something happened, that was an accident. What could we done? Would not have been able to do anything about it.
It helps it helps shape the kind of culture and... Of your organization when you're using language that you can... That implies you can do something about this rather than using language that suggests, there wasn't much you can have done about it. And it certainly applies with all the other training that, utility companies obviously utilize. Very training heavy organizations, a lot of other things that drivers can do or employees can do on the job site, and that's why driver safety sometimes takes the back seat. Right? So it's... There's a lot on the job that could affect a underground worker or a lineman or a troubleman that could really bring serious harm to them. But, the driver safety one, because it's also incredibly dangerous, definitely needs that awareness as well.
Yeah. That's such a great point, and I really like how you touched how that mindset affects safety culture. Because if you're just saying the word accident over and over again, then everyone's just viewing it as like, Oh, it's just an accident, no worries. But then the day it is recordable and a serious incident that happened. I think that's super important and a good learning for everyone.
So we've talked a lot about the driver behind the wheel. I want to zoom out just a little bit because the workforce itself is changing. People are coming into the jobs with really different levels of driving experience.
How does that change the way organizations should think about preparing someone to drive for work?
Yeah. It certainly is a real dynamic, certainly in more urban areas where, drivers didn't get a driver's license until much later in life than maybe they would have fifteen, twenty years ago. It it it is a real issue. There are some organizations that I'll speak with where, basically, that employee didn't get the driver's license, until they were employed, basically, as a con... As a condition of employment. And then as soon as, basically, they're employed and the job requires them to drive, it's it's not an ideal situation, unfortunately, but it's one that is very real for some of the companies that I, talk with and work with. So, instilling a lot of safeguards up front in the new hire training process is critical for that.
The companies that I work with that have the best safety practices and the best safety records are the ones that, for example, will not let their employee touch a company vehicle and put the company, basically, the company name at risk until they've gone through Smith system training. So organizations need to understand safety is paramount because when it goes wrong, it's incredibly costly to the organization from a reputation and ethos standpoint to, obviously, your bottom line because it comes down to revenue, expenses, protecting those, reducing risk. So catching employees on the front end with a kind of robust preventative proactive driver safety training program with the Smith system is critical for that before they get up on the job in everyday traffic and putting their employer at risk.
So our companies that see...
That implement that see the best success, rather than constantly having to chase it after the fact after they've already gone into the field there. They kind of put themselves behind the eight ball at that point.
Yeah. And you brought up definitely a good point around urban versus more suburb workforce. Just if you lived in New York, you might take the subway your whole life and then you change jobs and now you have to learn a whole new skill set that someone else has had years of experience doing. So I think that's a really good point to keep in mind as you're onboarding anyone to your organization.
Another big change that we keep hearing about is technology.
Many fleets do have cameras and telematics now. How is that changing the way organizations understand and manage driver risk?
Yes. So, I remember when telematics was really the hot, the hot commodity ten years ago, twelve years ago. There was a lot of buzz about it, much like there... There's a lot of buzz about AI right now, and we'll get to that in a second. But thinking back to just ten, twelve years ago, telematics, they're starting to be utilized across, fleet vehicles.
The rhetoric around it was really positive. People were thinking, oh, this is a game changer. This is this is this is the...
This is what we needed to, keep employees safe when behind the wheel. This is what was missing at the end of the day. But it didn't. It didn't fix the problem.
It...
More than anything, it just gave safety and risk professionals complete line of sight on what their drivers were actually doing. The devices by themselves went only so far to change behavior.
So instead, it just told, basically, the c suite how big the problem was, and then it put the onus on the safety professionals to do something about it. It's a really helpful tool. Smith System is one of the largest provider, telematics providers in the country because it does give you line of sight on, how your employees are performing. There's all the fleet related benefits as well.
But as a behavior based training company, we wanna use that as a tool to ensure that the training that we're instilling with the drivers on the front end with the driving the Smith system and driving the five keys, that it is sticking, that, that the drivers are doing what we have taught them to do. And telematics and now cameras give us a really good insight into doing that. But now that puts kind of the onus on a lot of the companies that are utilizing those tools, including AI cameras, as basically you put this in place, you would have...
You're almost in a better position. You would have been in a worse position if, or you are in a worse position now that you have line of sight on what your drivers are doing, but you didn't do anything about it compared to not knowing what they were doing. But then you didn't...
If you didn't know, you just kinda cross your fingers and hope it's not gonna be a big problem. So, that's why, basically, the behavior based training, taking action on the insights that that technology is generating and telling you what's going on in the vehicle is critical. You wanna be able to essentially now close the loop around a kind of holistic driver risk management program where drivers are getting the foundational training that they need. They're getting refresher training on those key concepts throughout the year because, again, driver safety is one of the most, driving safety.
That's one of the most dangerous things they do every day is driving. But then, having the right behavior based training tools around the insights where someone may have a harsh breaking incidents on a particular afternoon or was speeding or, was clearly distracted by looking at their cell phone, and the AI camera captures that. So at Smith System, what we do is, okay, you have line of sight on what those drivers are doing. Clearly, those things are not good, but those are indicative of behaviors that need proper training.
And we...
With the five keys, we've got the perfect training tool to help that driver understand. You you had eight harsh braking incidents the other day. It's rather than just telling the driver, stop that, you can then say to the driver, well, hey. Let's go back to key number one, aim high in steering, and key number two, get the big picture.
Let's talk about the, importance of looking further into your future and having the proper space cushion in front of with the vehicle in front of you. And when you have those two basic behaviors and habits implemented, you're now equipping the driver with what they need to stop triggering those events at the end of the day. So coupling coaching with pointing back to the proper training and using the technology to kind of connect those dots, is where we have seen the top performing fleets are performing the best, because they've kind of closed the loop with our programs in that regard rather than having a disconnected system where telematics or cameras, they're generating data, but they're not acting on it, or they're acting on it with a different program and not bringing it back to the five keys.
It can be disjointed with all these tools. So at Smith's system, our goal has been to use these tools, they're great tools, but bring them all back to the kind of foundational methodology around the five keys at the end of the day.
Yeah. And I think that's an amazing holistic approach. And how do you make sure that feels...
You definitely touched on this, but how do you make sure that it feels like support for the drivers versus just monitoring them?
Right. So naturally, a lot of big brother connotations are associated with telematics and cameras. At the end of the day, it's... If it's a company owned vehicle, meaning it is your vehicle, and it is that driver that is putting your company at risk when driving it. So you do need to, while I'm sure in some scenarios, navigate unions and all of that, messaging, training with the telematics and helping, the employee or the union, understand we're not here to get an employee in trouble. We're not... Certainly not here to get an employee fired or anything like that. We just want them to get to the job site safely, but ultimately get home safely.
More often than not, the utility companies that I speak with, the cameras are exonerating the drivers more than getting the drivers in trouble.
But also, like, if any of that weren't enough, we have a lot of really robust rewards programs as well for the drivers that are performing the best among their peers. So you ultimately want to, lead with carrots and not sticks, as I'm sure everyone knows, to drive behavior change.
But, in addition to that, with our program, we want the drivers to see how they're performing and have investment in it. So where some companies will have those big brother connotations because they keep all the camera and telematics data kind of behind closed doors for management to look at. First off, all the management that I speak with, they don't have the time of the day to go review all of that themselves. So that's that's kind of a misnomer for the drivers.
But the second element that you can use to kind of overcome that is show the drivers how they're doing with the same data. So now they're looking at everything, the exact same things that their manager might look at if they even wanted to to look at it. So not only do we give drivers complete line of sight of how they are performing when they are driving through traffic and driving with the five keys specifically, but we can then, with that tool, assign behavior based training to that driver if they are performing poorly. So we're not telling them, here's how you're doing, and then let them figure it out on themselves.
But we wanna give them the tool to change that habit, improve that behavior to get their scores back up. And, again, having that line of sight themselves really does help remove those kind of big brother connotations. There's nothing hidden essentially from the drivers at the end of the day.
Yeah. That's super helpful and a good reminder, you know, to everyone. And, you mentioned this, I think, in a couple questions prior, but from a safety leader's perspective, what should be happening before someone is handed the keys to a company vehicle?
Yeah. So, certainly, requiring the appropriate amount of training is important. Running MVRs is incredibly important as well. So if that's not part of your HR process, then certainly Fleet Earth Safety or both need to own that. That way you have visibility on, obviously, the validity of their driver's license. But if someone has a history of, traffic citations, I mean, that's something that you want to be aware of. So doing your homework before handing the driver keys to a vehicle is important in addition to the necessary training that you should probably be giving them before they take take the keys and start driving on the job on behalf of your your organization.
Yeah, absolutely.
And then as someone, as they're going through the training, they get it. Six months later, it might not be top of mind anymore. That might be a common issue. So what should organizations be doing throughout the year to keep driver safety from becoming something people only talk about during training?
Right. That's a huge issue that I see with companies that are basically trying to build a driver safety culture from scratches. They know on the front end, basically, the Smith System foundational training is really good. It's really important.
It has a lasting effect. Some employees often that I speak with, they'll they'll remember one or two of the five keys ten years, fifteen years after they've had the training. So not a lot of other training, training programs out there can do that. So it is impactful.
It does resonate, but they all...
They...
It's rare they can tell me all five keys. Right? So how do you drive that awareness, year round is the great way to think about this because, again, this is the most dangerous thing that employees do in The United States.
It's driving. It's... Again, it kills more people, and it injures more people on the job than anything else.
So driving that awareness is really important year round. There's a lot of different ways organizations can do that. We have our continual learning elearning program that can do that, but just bringing it up in safety meetings, kind of tailgate talks or discussions, having coaching sessions in person with a driver around their telematics or camera data, safety messages from senior leadership, the CEO, or someone that's very high up in the c suite of organization sharing just like a PSA to everyone. April's distracted driving awareness month really drive that home and all of kind of, like, your initiatives across the organization, to help all of your employees understand that this is really important. And, having the kind of accountability policies to back that up as well, really helps that resonate. So there's a lot of different ways you can drive that awareness from both a training, but also culture and messaging standpoint.
Yeah. Thank you. That's super helpful and just a good reminder to keep that top of mind year round.
I know we're getting right about on time. So if you could just close this out with someone listening today wanted to strengthen their driver safety approach, what would you have them look at first?
Yeah. I mean, of course, look at Smith system. We've been doing this for a really long time.
But what I would obviously, aside from plugging our organization is I would if you're especially a safety professional and you know crashes are a problem, go to your...
Typically be your risk management department and understand how much crashes are costing your organization every year, both from a frequency standpoint, but also severity and try to get those comprehensive comprehensive costs as much as possible. Should be easy to data to track down because most of those organizations are all self insured. So try to understand how much how much did we pay in workers' comp, vehicle repairs, or what was the deductible, claims, damage to a customer site, and doing the appropriate repairs there, litigation. I mean, it...
The impact on finances to an organization around crashes can be huge, and people don't necessarily know it or realize it. So if you know it's a problem, I would always say try to get with risk management. Sometimes fleet will have really good data as far as basically how much they're they're paying out in repairs, things like that on company vehicles, and try to get a really good grasp of how big the problem is. And then after you do that, just kinda self diagnose.
Okay. What kind of, crashes are causing these problems? Is there a trend? Is it a certain areas?
Is it a certain crash type? Is it a certain demographic of drivers in a certain business unit? Whatever it may be, try to understand kind of what those underlying factors are, and then implementing programs like Smith's system are just gonna make solving the solutions that much more effective.
Well, Nate, thank you so much. This was such a practical conversation, and I think everyone's gonna walk away with a lot to think about. We just so appreciate you taking the time today to walk us through all this.
Thanks for the invite.
Yeah, of course, anytime.
And then on the screen here, you'll see if you want to scan that QR code. If you want to connect with Smith, how to bring training to your organization, feel free to scan that code.
Next, if you scan this QR code, you'll see a few driving safety resources for you, so feel free to grab those. We will also send, you know, a replay email out with this recording and these resources, so feel free to check your inbox there.
Lastly, if you want to stay in the know for our upcoming live events, feel free to scan this code, and we'll make sure to keep you in the loop there. Thank you, Nate. Thanks, everyone, for joining us, and we'll see you next time.
Put It Into Action
Related bonus resources to help you apply the concepts.
Driving Safety Toolbox Talks & Videos
Ready-to-use videos and toolbox talks on backing, road rage and the drive home, built to help crews avoid preventable crashes.
Stay Up-to-Date on Upcoming Vimocity Events
Fill out the form to get updates on future discussions with industry experts.